Michael Hiles Blog

by Michael Hiles | |

Ok, so aside from Google+, the latest excitement in the social media world is Klout. Klout has made an effort to promote the idea that people with a higher "Klout Score" somehow or another have more… well… clout on the internet.
 
Here’s the big problem with that entire idea.
 
Klout’s proprietary algorithm is at best, incomplete, and at the worst, self serving.  Not that my own Klout score is without some level of merit. I’m probably in the 90th percentile of social media users, although I am nowhere close to some of the social media titans like Brogan, Kawasaki, Pirillo, Scoble, Dave Morin, et al.
 
But in the grand scheme of things, I contend Klout is simply meaningless. It’s an attempt to create some idea of a standard where none can be created.
 
Does Klout take into consideration a database of 100,000+ email newsletter subscribers?
 
How about that discussion forum in a niche that has 100,000+ subscribers?
 
Yeah, that’s what I thought.No show.

In fact, there's some regular media celebs and NY Times best-selling authors with Klout scores in the single digits.

Yet, the band plays on.
 
That’s the beauty of the internet, anyone can declare themselves an arbiter or authority. And on the internet, there’s always millions of quiet folks you’ve never heard of, silently disproving your entire reality by merely existing.
 
Now here's the sad/scary part. Microsoft has proven over and over that all one has to do in order to declare a standard is 1) declare the standard, and 2) get enough people to buy into the idea that the standard they declared is really a standard.
 
Ironic, huh.



Comments

Angie
Monday, November 07, 2011 7:40 AM
I couldn't agree more, Michael. It's far too incomplete to be a metric that I would focus on. And, at the end of the day, it has no direct correlation to my online success.

But, I have a sector of my readers that is currently being cornered in Klout. The brands and PR firms have jumped on this as being one of the end all and be all's of which bloggers they will work with. As is usually the case, I think there are far more important things that I would be looking at if it were me looking for advertising. But, it's not. :)
Michael Hiles
Tuesday, November 08, 2011 6:52 AM
Sure, all it takes is for enough people to accept the "standard" for it to become a "standard".

Since I posted this article, I have continued to use Klout - and actually have found one redeeming value. It helps me measure and track my own engagement as sort of a reminder sort of tool. But the problem is that I had a pretty good handle on the algorithm of what kinds of engagements are higher weighting on their scale... and then they went and changed the entire thing.

So I am still not really all that big of a fan myself. Maybe it will grow, but it will always be an approximation at best. I guess we live in that kind of world.

Post Comment

Name (required)

Email (required)

Website

CAPTCHA image
Enter the code shown above:

Subscribe To My Newsletter




      

Stalk Me...

     
Follow Michael on Twitter...

Community Tools

Who Am I?

Michael Hiles
Michael Hiles...
Serial Entrepreneur,
Business Development Guy,
Technology Geek,
Writer, Speaker,
Husband, and Daddy